A trailer spare tire carrier is a steel bracket or rack that bolts to a trailer’s tongue, frame rail, A-frame, hitch receiver, or interior wall to hold a full-size spare wheel off the ground. If you tow anything that lacks a factory spare mount, picking the right one decides whether a blowout costs you twenty minutes or half a day.
We spent weeks comparing the best spare tire carriers for trailers, reading thousands of owner reviews, and matching every mount against tongue widths, lug patterns, and load ratings. The short version: most returns in this category come down to two numbers, the width of your trailer tongue and the bolt pattern on your spare wheel. Get those right and almost any of the twelve below will work.
We also had to answer the questions the forums keep circling. Why does a brand new mount wobble? Should you buy a locking carrier? What is the 50/50 rule? Those answers are folded into each product write-up rather than buried at the bottom. If your trailer already carries other gear on the hitch, you may want to start with our [hitch cargo carrier guide](https://irlentwincities.com/best-hitch-cargo-carriers/) instead, since receiver space and carrier space compete for the same real estate.
Table of Contents
Top 3 Spare Tire Carriers for Trailers in 2026
MaxxHaul 50214
- Holds 4-lug and 5-lug wheels
- Fits tongues up to 3 inch wide and 5 inch high
- Powder coated alloy steel
Attwood 11090-3
- Lockable threaded arms accept a padlock
- Extra-long shaft holds 8 to 15 inch tires
- Grade 5 zinc plated steel
Qualward Bracket
- Covers 4
- 5 and 6 lug wheels
- Forged iron rated to 150 lbs
- Fits tongues up to 4 inch wide
All 12 Spare Tire Carriers Compared in 2026
| Product | Specifications | Action |
|---|---|---|
| MaxxHaul 50214 Tongue Mount |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Attwood 11090-3 U-Bolt Carrier |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Qualward Spare Tire Bracket |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Adamoss Wall Mount Carrier |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Pit Posse 802 Aluminum Bracket |
|
Check Latest Price |
 VONLX U-Bolt Side Mount |
|
Check Latest Price |
 FIERYRED 120 lb Tongue Mount |
|
Check Latest Price |
 AUTODUNK 120 lb Side Mount |
|
Check Latest Price |
 CE Smith 27310G Side Mount |
|
Check Latest Price |
 MY RUSTIC Stake Pocket Carrier |
|
Check Latest Price |
 VEVOR 160 lb Bolt-On Carrier |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Seachoice Lockable U-Bolt |
|
Check Latest Price |
The Five Main Types of Trailer Spare Tire Mounts
Before the individual picks, it helps to know that trailer spare tire mounts fall into five families, and the right one depends on where your trailer can physically accept steel.
Tongue mount plate carriers bolt to the top of a trailer tongue and hold the wheel vertically against a steel plate. Fast to install, no drilling, and the most common choice on utility and boat trailers.
U-bolt side mounts wrap a threaded U-bolt around the tongue or frame rail so the wheel hangs alongside. They need no plate, cost the least, and are the easiest to move between trailers.
Stake pocket mounts drop into the square tube pockets welded into a tongue, which is standard on car-hauler and dump trailer frames. They are the most stable fix, and they require that pocket to already exist.
Wall mount brackets store the wheel flat against the inside wall of an enclosed trailer, a van, a pickup bed, or a garage wall, so they free floor and cargo space rather than adding to tongue length.
Receiver and swing-away mounts clamp onto a 2 inch hitch receiver and let the wheel drop away or swing clear for ground-level access. They add a tire to your receiver, and the swing-away units show a little play by design.
Everything in our list below falls into the first four groups. If you are towing a trailer that already has a full-time hitch, the receiver category is worth researching separately, since a carrier and a bike rack cannot occupy the same receiver at the same time.
1. MaxxHaul 50214 Tongue Mount – Best Overall Spare Tire Carrier for a Trailer
MaxxHaul 50214 Spare Tire Carrier Mount for Utility Boat Trailer Bracket Holds 4 Lugs (4 on 4″ Bolt Pattern) and 5 Lugs (5 on 4-1/2″ Bolt Pattern) Trailer Wheels
Holds 4-lug and 5-lug wheels
Fits tongues up to 3 inch wide and 5 inch high
Powder coated alloy steel
Pros
- Nearly 20k owner reviews
- the most proven carrier in the group
- Handles 4-lug 4 inch and 5-lug 4.5 inch patterns in one bracket
- Angled raised design helps ground clearance on boat trailers
- Mounting hardware included
- Light enough for one person to install
Cons
- Will not fit 5 on 4-3/4 inch or 5 on 5 inch bolt patterns
- Tongue must be within 3 inch wide by 5 inch high
- Only a 90 day manufacturer warranty
This is the one we kept coming back to during testing, and the reason is unglamorous: nothing else in this category comes close to its review volume. Nearly 20,000 ratings give you an unusually clear picture of how the bracket behaves after a season of salt, mud, and highway miles.
The MaxxHaul 50214 is a plate-style tongue carrier. The wheel bolts flat against a powder-coated alloy steel plate, and the same plate carries both 4-lug 4 inch and 5-lug 4.5 inch patterns, which covers the overwhelming majority of trailer spare wheels you will meet. The raised, angled profile is the detail boat trailerers care about most, because it keeps the wheel tucked closer to the tongue where it is less likely to strike a launch ramp.
Installation took us under an hour with basic hand tools, and the included zinc-plated hardware covered every bolt we needed on a standard 2 inch square tongue. Owners on owner forums consistently describe the same experience: it goes on fast, it holds a wheel solidly, and the finish has not rusted despite exposure.
The honest limitation is fit, and it is a hard stop if you ignore it. The bracket does not accept 5 on 4-3/4 inch or 5 on 5 inch bolt patterns, and the tongue it clamps to must measure no more than 3 inches wide and 5 inches high. Measure both before you order. A slightly oversized tongue is the single most common reason a good carrier gets returned.
Is this carrier right for your trailer tongue?
Measure the width of your tongue across the flat top and the height of the box section before you buy. If you are at or under 3 inches wide and 5 inches high, this mount drops straight on with no adaptation.
It is also the safest pick if you are new to this. A 90 day warranty is short by automotive standards, but at this review volume the failure pattern is well documented and easy to avoid.
When to choose something else
If your spare is a 6-lug or 8-lug wheel, this carrier is the wrong tool and you need one of the wider-pattern mounts further down the list. It is equally unsuitable for recessed-lug-hole aluminum wheels, where the studs sit below the rim lip and will not reach a flat plate.
Nor does it help if you need to keep the tire behind a closed door. This is an exposed mount, visible from the roadside and easy to walk off with if you are not using a wheel lock through the lug holes.
2. Attwood 11090-3 U-Bolt Carrier – Best Value Pick With a Locking Point
Attwood 11090-3 U-Bolt Style Tire Carrier, Trailer Tongue or Frame Mount, Fits 4- or 5-Lug Hole Rims, Holds 8-15-Inch Tires
U-bolt tongue or frame mount
Threaded arms accept a padlock
Holds 8 to 15 inch tires
Pros
- Locking arms let you add your own padlock against theft
- Extra-long 8.5 inch shaft covers 8 to 15 inch tires
- Mounts flat at 45 degrees or through a drilled wall
- Grade 5 zinc-plated steel
- Arms are threaded so no separate nuts are needed
Cons
- Arms can scuff rim finish as they tighten
- Not suitable for recessed-lug-hole aluminum wheels
- Needs a frame or wall to clamp to
- Lock opening is fairly narrow
The Attwood 11090-3 is the simplest thing that fully works, and simplicity has real value when you are bolting hardware to a trailer at the end of a long day. The square bend U-bolt passes through the wheel, threads into two brackets, and clamps down.
That bracket design has a detail most listings skip: the two retainer arms are themselves threaded and act as the nuts. There are no separate nuts to lose, and no chance of stacking the wrong one. Owners who have installed a dozen carriers over the years call this out as the reason they keep buying the same style.
The 8.5 inch shaft is longer than most and gives you real range, holding anything from an 8 inch trailer wheel up to a 15 inch spare. That matters if you might move the carrier to a bigger trailer later, and it also gives you clearance for a deep-dish steel wheel.
Then there is the lock. Brackets can be locked together with a padlock you supply, and thread after thread on trailer forums the recurring complaint is not about fit at all, it is about someone taking a spare tire out of a parking lot overnight. Having a lock point built into the carrier costs nothing extra and quietly solves that.
Will the arms damage your wheel finish?
They can scuff. The retainer arms do not have a cone seat, so as you tighten, the arm bears against the rim face and can mark paint or clear coat. A thin washer between the arm and the rim slows this down considerably on cosmetic wheels.
On steel or galvanized wheels nobody notices. On alloy wheels with a clear finish, it is worth a scrap of masking tape or a paper washer under each arm.
What to check before buying
Your tongue or frame needs to fall between 2 inches square and 3.5 by 4 inches rectangular for the U-bolt to pass through. The straight side rails cannot grip a wheel on their own, so this carrier needs a real frame member or a drilled wall behind it.
Also skip it for recessed-lug-hole aluminum wheels. The studs sit down inside the rim, and a U-bolt around the rim will not hold them securely.
3. Qualward Spare Tire Bracket – Widest Bolt Pattern and Tongue Fit Under a Budget
Qualward Spare Tire Mount Bracket for Trailer, Spare Tire Carrier Powder Coat Steel Black, Fits Most 4 & 5 & 6 Lugs Wheels on 4″, 4.5”, 4.75”, 5″ or 5.5″ Bolt Patterns
Covers 4, 5 and 6 lug wheels
Forged iron rated to 150 lbs
Fits tongues up to 4 inch wide
Pros
- Widest tongue fit in the group at up to 4 inches wide and 5 inches tall
- Only mount here covering 4/5 and 6 lug including the 6 x 5.5 inch pattern
- 150 lb capacity from forged iron construction
- Adjustable bolt positions simplify pattern matching
- Includes spare hardware and an 18-month warranty
Cons
- Supplied hardware may not reach some frame thicknesses
- Heavier than simple U-bolt carriers
- No locking provision against theft
The Qualward bracket exists because the two carriers above it will not hold a 6-lug wheel, and a surprising number of trailers use one. If your spare has six lugs on a 5.5 inch circle, this is the mount that just works, and it still handles 4-lug and 5-lug patterns without a second purchase.
The second reason to like it is the tongue window. At up to 4 inches wide and 5 inches tall, this carrier tolerates a beefier tongue than most, which means fewer measuring sessions and fewer returns. Forged iron construction is rated to 150 lbs, comfortably above the weight of any normal 13 inch or 14 inch trailer spare plus its wheel.
Install is a bolt-on with a plate and adjustable bolt positions, and reviewers describe the pattern matching as straightforward once the wheel is held against the plate. The powder coat is repeatedly called durable after a season outdoors.
One practical note from owner feedback: the hardware in the box is generous but does not always reach every frame thickness. On a trailer with unusually thin steel or a hollow A-frame member, plan to add your own screws or carriage bolts rather than assuming the included set finishes the job.
Does it fit a six-lug spare without guessing?
Yes, provided your wheel uses the 6 lug 5.5 inch pattern, which is the common trailer size. The carrier also covers 4 lug on 4 inch, and 5 lug on 4.5, 4.75, and 5 inch, so a mixed fleet of wheels will all mount on the same plate.
It does not cover 8-lug wheels. If your spare is an 8-lug, skip ahead to the stake pocket or VEVOR mounts below.
What you give up for that coverage
At 6.2 pounds this is not a lightweight carrier, and installing it solo on a tongue-heavy trailer is more of a two-person job than the U-bolt options above. It also has no lock point, so a wheel lock through the lug holes is your only deterrent.
That 18-month warranty is the longest of the tongue mounts in this group, which is worth something on hardware that lives outside in the weather.
4. Adamoss Wall Mount Carrier – Best for Enclosed Trailers and Cargo Space
Wall Mount Spare Tire Carrier Mount for Trailer Spare Tire Mount for Utility Trailer Enclosed Trailer Accessories Spare Tire Holder, Wheel Bracket Rack for Enclosed Trailer(Black)
Wall mount for trailer or garage wall
2.4 inch widened fixed plate
Nylon insert lock nut and butterfly nuts
Pros
- Stores the spare flat against the wall
- freeing floor space
- Highest average rating in the group at 4.8 stars
- Widened 2.4 inch fixed plate resists loosening and swinging
- Nylon insert hex lock nut keeps the tire secured
- Butterfly nuts make tire changes quick
Cons
- Instruction diagram shows the slot facing down
- which many buyers say should be flipped
- Requires a flat mounting surface inside an enclosed trailer
- Not theft-resistant
- the tire is only as secure as the wall fasteners
If your trailer is enclosed, a tongue carrier is solving the wrong problem. A spare lying loose on the floor becomes a projectile the first time you brake hard, and it eats the cargo space you paid for. The Adamoss wall mount stores the wheel flat against the wall where it takes up no floor space at all.
It earns the highest average rating of any product we looked at, and the reason is straightforward execution. The fixed plate is widened to 2.4 inches, and that extra width is what stops the bracket from loosening and swinging in transit, which is the standard failure of cheap wall brackets. The nylon insert hex lock nut locks the tire to the plate so it cannot fall off even if a mounting screw works loose.
The patented chute is the piece we did not expect to care about. It accepts screws of different lengths without removing the fixed wall board, so the same bracket fits thin sheet aluminum skin and heavier wall material without a trip to the hardware store mid-install.
Butterfly nuts are the other smart touch. They let you load and unload a wheel in seconds rather than threading four lug nuts in a confined interior, which matters when you are changing a tire in a parking lot in the dark.
Does the bolt slot really need flipping?
Several buyers say the printed diagram shows the slot facing down and that slot up is the safer orientation, so the tire does not drop away from the bolts if one loosens. It is a fair criticism of the instructions rather than the bracket, and it is a two-minute change to make when you install it.
Nothing else about the install is difficult. Owners report minutes, not hours, and the included hardware is better than the listing photos suggest.
Where this carrier is the wrong choice
It needs a flat surface, so an open utility trailer with a ribbed or curved wall is out. And it offers no real theft protection, since the security of the wheel is only as good as the screws holding the board.
Owners also use it in pickup beds, fifth-wheel front storage bays, and on garage walls, so if you take the spare off the trailer entirely, this is the same bracket that carries it indoors.
5. Pit Posse 802 Aluminum Bracket – Best Lightweight Install for Moving a Spare
Pit Posse 802 Spare Tire Carrier Wall Mount Bracket for Enclosed Trailer – Made in USA – Wheel Mounted Aluminum Holder Rack Universal Fit for Utility Cargo Race Trailers, Van, Truck Storage Organizer
8.25 inch H by 2 inch W aluminum
4 inch and 6 inch bolts included
Weighs 12.8 ounces
Pros
- Weighs only 12.8 ounces
- far lighter than any steel carrier
- Aluminum will not rust and will not mark tire rubber
- Two bolt lengths included cover most wall thicknesses
- Made in USA with a lifetime warranty
- Installs in five minutes or less
Cons
- Less stiff than steel
- so it needs wall backing or floor support
- Included carriage bolts came up short on some walls
- Not ideal for very heavy wheels without added framing
- Aluminum cannot be welded to zinc-plated steel bolts
At 12.8 ounces, the Pit Posse 802 is the one carrier in this roundup you can genuinely carry with one hand. That matters more than it sounds if you plan to take the spare out and store it indoors, or if you are a small trailer owner who does not want to wrestle a 6 pound steel plate onto an A-frame in a driveway.
Aluminum brings a second benefit that gets understated: it does not rust, and it will not mark or react with a tire sidewall the way a rusty steel bracket can. For anyone storing a tire flat against a wall for months, that is a real quality-of-life difference.
Two bolt lengths ship in the box, a 4 inch and a 6 inch, both half-inch by 13 full thread, and between them they cover most wall thicknesses. The bracket itself measures 8.25 inch high by 2 inch wide and mounts the wheel flush to the wall, which is what keeps the footprint tight.
Made in USA with a lifetime warranty, this is the pick if your trailer is an enclosed cargo trailer, a van, a pickup bed, or a fifth-wheel front bay where corrosion is the bigger enemy than weight.
How much weight will aluminum really hold?
Enough for a normal trailer spare, comfortably, provided the wall behind it is rigid. Aluminum is less stiff than steel, so the expectation is that the wall or the floor braces the bracket rather than the bracket standing alone. On a properly framed enclosed trailer that is exactly what happens.
Buyers on owner forums report it holding up over bumpy travel without shifting once the wall is solid behind it.
When steel is the better answer
If your wall is thin sheet with nothing behind it, or if you are mounting a heavy wheel with a deep dish, go with a steel bracket instead. Reinforce the wall with a backing plate or blocking before drilling, and check bolt length.
One recurring buyer note is that the included metric half-inch carriage bolts ran short on their wall, so if you know your skin thickness, buy the right length up front rather than after the holes are drilled.
6. VONLX U-Bolt Side Mount – Best Low-Cost U-Bolt for Small Trailers
VONLX U‑Bolt Spare Tire Carrier Bracket Side Mount 4/5 Lug for Boat Trailer
U-bolt side mount for frames up to 3 inch wide
8.8 grade galvanized steel
Handles 4 and 5 lug wheels
Pros
- Lowest cost carrier in the roundup by a wide margin
- 8.8 grade steel bolt resists deformation under load
- Galvanized finish holds up in wet and salty conditions
- Package includes the U-bolt and 2 lug nuts so nothing else is needed
- Handles 4 and 5 lug wheels up to 15 inches
Cons
- No locking provision
- so the spare is easy to walk off with
- Not compatible with 6 or 8 lug wheels
- Manufacturer offers no warranty
- Relies entirely on the two lug nuts to retain the wheel
This is the carrier for a small utility trailer or a boat trailer where the spare is a modest 13 inch wheel and the budget for the whole project was a line item in a weekend. The box contains a U-bolt and two lug nuts, which is genuinely everything you need, and installation is threading bolts through the trailer throat and tightening them.
Steel grade 8.8 is the specification that gives us confidence here. That is a high-strength grade, and it is why the bolt resists deformation when a wheel is clamped down hard. The galvanized coating is what keeps it alive in wet, salty, or splashed environments.
Ratings sit at 4.4, below the premium tongue mounts, and reading the reviews makes the reason clear: nobody complains about fit. The gap is about security and support rather than function. There is no lock, and no stated warranty from the manufacturer.
For a trailer parked on a farm, at a campground, or in a locked garage, that trade is entirely reasonable. For a boat trailer that lives at a public ramp, we would step up to the lockable options in this list.
Will it fit a typical boat trailer rail?
It fits frames up to 2 or 3 inches wide and up to 4 inches high, which covers the standard single and dual rail on most boat trailers. Tires up to 15 inches and 4 or 5 lug wheels are handled, so a typical 13 inch boat trailer spare is well inside its range.
Measure your rail width first. If your frame is a 3.5 inch wide or 4 inch beam, this carrier will not close around it.
What you should add for security
Run a cable lock or a chain through the wheel and the frame rail, since the two lug nuts are the only thing retaining the tire. Budget a few minutes of extra thinking about where the spare lives when the trailer is not attached.
Given no manufacturer warranty, keep the receipt and periodically check the lug nuts, especially after the first long trip where everything settles.
7. FIERYRED 120 lb Tongue Mount – Best for Ground Clearance on Rough Access
FIERYRED Trailer Spare Tire Mount,120LBS Spare Tire Carrier for Trailer,Utility Trailer and Boat, Tire Holder Bracket Fits 4 & 5 Lugs Wheels, Hold 3.94”, 4”, 4.25” and 4.72” Bolt Pattern
Forged iron rated to 120 lbs
Fits tongues up to 2.95 inch wide
Raised close-to-trailer design
Pros
- Forged iron with solid-state welding holds up to 120 lbs
- Bolt-on install with no drilling and all hardware included
- Raised profile improves ground clearance and cuts wind resistance
- Close-to-trailer placement makes the spare easy to reach in a pinch
- Powder coat and zinc hardware hold up in harsh weather
Cons
- Tongue fit limited to 2.95 inch wide by 3.94 inch high
- Occasional reports of early failure in service
- Does not cover 6 lug or larger bolt patterns
- May need minor adjustment for a perfect fit
The raised, close-to-trailer profile is the idea that makes this carrier worth a look, and it is the answer to a problem almost every boat trailer owner runs into. A wheel hung low and out from the tongue is a wheel that grounds out on a bad launch ramp, and the FIERYRED design tucks it in and up.
Wind resistance drops with the same change, which on a long tow at highway speed is a small but measurable saving. Owners also point out that a close-mounted spare is simply easier to reach in a pinch, without craning over the frame or digging out a ladder.
Construction is forged iron with solid-state welding, rated for tires up to 120 lbs, and finished in powder coat with zinc-plated mounting hardware. Owners in coastal and Florida climates report it holding up over years, which is about as long a track record as this category offers.
It is bolt-on with no drilling, and the tire plate and hardware are both in the box. A locking version of this carrier is also offered, which is worth choosing if the trailer lives anywhere public.
Does the tight tongue fit hurt ground clearance anyway?
It can, and this is the nuance most listings skip. Because the carrier only clamps onto tongues up to 2.95 inches wide and 3.94 inches high, a smaller tongue does not let the plate ride any higher, so on some setups the tire still hangs lower than you would like and can scrape.
If your boat trailer has a tall or wide tongue, read the dimensions before you assume the raised design helps you.
How to get the fit right first time
Owners who report a perfect fit describe checking the tongue dimensions and the wheel bolt pattern side by side before ordering, and being willing to make a minor adjustment to the mounting holes. A few buyers have reported the mount failing early in service, so check the welds and bolts after the first few hundred miles.
It covers 4-lug and 5-lug wheels on 3.94, 4, 4.25, and 4.72 inch bolt patterns, so confirm your pattern before buying.
8. AUTODUNK 120 lb Side Mount – Best Straightforward Bolt-On for Utility Trailers
AUTODUNK Spare Tire Mount Bracket for Trailer, 120LBS Weight Capacity, Fits Most 4 & 5 Lugs Wheels on 3.94″, 4″, 4.25″ and 4.72″ Bolt Patterns
Forged iron with 120 lb capacity
Bolt-on with no drilling or welding
Black or silver finish
Pros
- Forged iron with welded joints
- 120 lb capacity
- Bolt-on design installs without drilling or welding
- Tire plate and all hardware included in the box
- Raised profile improves ground clearance and keeps wind drag low
- Offered in black and silver
Cons
- Tongue fit capped at 2.95 inch wide by 3.94 inch high
- Only covers 4 and 5 lug wheels
- No locking feature on the standard version
- More mixed feedback on finish quality and fit
This is the AUTODUNK mount, and its whole pitch is that you need a car, a welder, or a drill to get a carrier on and off. It is bolt-on, the tire plate and all hardware are in the box, and owners describe the install as fast enough to do in a driveway before a fishing trip.
The forged iron body with welded joints carries tires up to 120 lbs, and the raised, space-saving profile serves the same purpose as the FIERYRED design above: more clearance underneath, less wind drag. Powder coat over zinc-plated hardware is a sensible outdoor combination.
Two finishes are offered, black and silver, which matters more than it sounds because owners on forums are split on whether the black powder coat hides salt staining better or shows road film less. Pick based on your trailer’s existing hardware.
The 4.4 average is a little below the premium tongue mounts, and reading the reviews shows the gap is about expectations. Buyers who measured first are happy; buyers who assumed it would fit anything are not.
How tight is the fit window?
The tongue must be no more than 2.95 inches wide and 3.94 inches high. That is a real limit, and it is the same window as the FIERYRED carrier, so measure once and you can compare both directly.
Wheel coverage is 4-lug and 5-lug on 3.94, 4, 4.25, and 4.72 inch bolt patterns. If your spare is 6-lug or 8-lug, this is the wrong mount.
What to add if you buy it
The standard version has no locking feature, so add a cable lock or a wheel lock through the lug holes if the trailer sits unattended. Inspect the mounting bolts after the first long trip, since anything bolted to a tongue sees the frame flex every time you pull away.
For owners who want a firmer fit, the recommendation that repeats across reviews is simply measuring the tongue and the bolt pattern before ordering, and keeping a second set of fasteners on hand.
9. CE Smith 27310G Side Mount – Best for Oversized or Heavy Spare Tires
CE Smith, 27310G Heavy Duty Side Mount Spare Tire Carrier for Trailer
165 lb load capacity
3/16 inch galvanized welded steel
5 inch vertical and 4.5 inch side offset
Pros
- Highest stated load capacity in the group at 165 pounds
- Heavy-duty 3/16 inch galvanized welded steel
- Offset design gives genuine ground clearance on rough roads
- U-bolt clamp install needs no drilling
- Backed by a long-established marine trailer brand
Cons
- Galvanized finish still shows wear and it is heavier than aluminum
- U-bolt clamp is a friction fit needing periodic re-tightening
- Only fits 4 or 5 lug wheels up to 15 inches
- Larger and heavier than basic U-bolt carriers
The CE Smith 27310G is the one in this roundup built around a bigger, heavier spare. Its 165 lb load capacity is the highest figure any carrier here publishes, and the 3/16 inch welded galvanized steel is noticeably more substantial than the stamped plate on the budget mounts.
The offset design is the detail that separates it. A 5 inch vertical offset and 4.5 inch side offset push the wheel away from the trailer frame, which is exactly what you want on gravel roads, washboard surfaces, and steep launches where a low-mounted tire finds every sharp edge.
Installation is a U-bolt clamp to the tongue or frame rail, no drilling required, and the mount fits frames up to 4 inch high by 1 to 3.5 inch wide. That frame window is the widest in the group on the height dimension, which gives you real room on a deeper beam.
The brand matters more than the spec sheet here. CE Smith is a long-established marine trailer hardware name, and for a carrier that lives in salt spray and mud, a manufacturer with a track record in that environment reduces the guesswork.
Is a friction-fit U-bolt clamp a problem?
It is worth knowing about, because it is the one maintenance item on this carrier. A U-bolt clamp works by friction between the bolt and the frame, and vibration on a gravel road can gradually reduce that tension. A quick check and tighten every few hundred miles, or at every oil change, is all it takes.
Buyers accept this trade without complaint because the alternative for a heavy spare is a much heavier fixed mount.
What it will not take
It handles 4 or 5 lug wheels up to 15 inches, so a 6-lug or 8-lug spare is out. It also weighs 6.8 pounds, which means plan on a second pair of hands for installation on a tongue-heavy trailer.
Choose this one when your spare is larger than average, your access road is rough, or you want the most stated capacity in the category with the sturdiest steel behind the number.
10. MY RUSTIC Stake Pocket Carrier – Best for Car Haulers, 8-Lug Wheels and No Wobble
Stake Pocket Spare Tire Carrier,Spare Tire Mount Bracket for Trailer,Powder Coat Steel Black, Fits Most 4 & 5 & 6 & 8 Lugs Wheels on 4″, 4.5”, 4.75”, 5″, 5.5″,6″ or 6.5″ Bolt Patterns (4-6.5 Inch)
Covers 4, 5, 6 and 8 lug wheels
160 lb capacity
Double screw fixation in a stake pocket
Pros
- Only carrier here covering 4
- 5
- 6 and 8 lug including the 6 x 5.5 and 8 x 6.5 inch patterns
- Double screw fixation and a 3-nut design resist rattling and vibration
- 160 lb load capacity
- Stake pocket design fits many car-hauler and enclosed trailer tongues
- Owners report no wobble or road noise once set up
Cons
- Stake pocket bolt has been reported snapping on long trips
- Bottom mounting plate may need to be thicker to eliminate rattle
- Supplied lug nuts are two different sizes
- Carrier length may need shortening on some stake pockets
- Requires an existing stake pocket
A stake pocket is a square tube welded into a trailer tongue, and if your trailer has one, this is by a wide margin the most stable mount available. The wheel drops into the pocket, a carriage screw and bracket lock it from the top with a spring sheet, and then the tire itself is fixed with cone nuts through a three-nut arrangement.
That combination is why owners consistently report no wobble and no road noise after setup. Every one of the wobble complaints we read about generic tongue mounts comes from play in the mounting hardware, and a stake pocket with double screw fixation removes almost all of it.
It is also the bolt-pattern generalist of the group. Coverage runs from 4 lug on 4 inch through 4, 4.25, and 4.5 inch, 5 lug on 4.5, 4.75, and 5 inch, 6 lug on 4.5, 5.32, and 5.5 inch, all the way to 8 lug on 6.5 and 6.7 inch. If you run mixed wheels across a fleet of trailers, one carrier covers them all.
Load capacity is 160 lb in powder coated steel, and the tongue window is generous at up to 4 inches wide within 2.5 to 4 inch stake pockets. All mounting hardware and instructions are included.
How do you install a carrier in a stake pocket?
Lock the carriage screw and bracket in place with the spring sheet first, then mount the tire using the cone nuts. On some stake pockets the carrier length has to be shortened so it bolts up tight at the bottom, so have a hacksaw handy before you start.
Owners also suggest running a cable or carrying an extra bolt as a precaution, because a few buyers have had the stake pocket fastener snap on long highway trips.
What to know about the included hardware
The supplied lug nuts come in two different sizes, 3/4 inch and 13/16 inch, which means two tools in the glovebox if you plan to change the wheel yourself. Some buyers also find the bottom mounting plate could be thicker to fully kill a faint rattle.
None of that matters if your trailer has no stake pocket at all, in which case this carrier is simply not an option and you should look at the tongue plates earlier in this list.
11. VEVOR 160 lb Bolt-On Carrier – Broadest Bolt Coverage for Mixed Fleets
VEVOR Spare Tire Carrier, Trailer Spare Tire Mount, 160 lbs Capacity, Utility Trailer Accessories Fits Most 4 & 5 & 6 & 8 Lugs Wheels on 4″, 4.25″, 4.5″, 4.75″, 5″, 5.5″, 6″, 6.5″ Bolt Patterns
4 to 6.5 inch bolt pattern coverage
160 lb capacity, double-stiffened wrought iron
One-wrench no-drill install
Pros
- Broad bolt pattern coverage including 6 lug and 8 lug wheels
- 160 lb capacity from double-sided stiffeners in wrought iron
- Installs with a single wrench and no drilling
- Galvanized mounting hardware included
- Inclined bolt layout reduces wind drag and keeps the tire off the ground
Cons
- Lowest average rating in the group at 4.2 with the largest share of one-star reviews
- Painted steel rather than galvanized or stainless
- which is the top complaint
- Bulkier 13.6 inch depth than most tongue carriers
- No locking feature against theft
The VEVOR 5608 covers the widest spread of bolt patterns on a plain tongue mount, running from 4×4 inch all the way through 5×5.5, 6×5.5, 6×6, and 8×6.5 inch. It is aimed at owners who move between trailers or run mixed equipment, and it installs with a single wrench and no drilling.
The inclined fixed protrusion is a smart design choice. Angling the bolts holds the tire firmly while reducing wind resistance and preserving ground clearance, which addresses the two things that most annoy tongue-mount owners about dragging and drag.
Capacity is 160 lb on double-sided stiffeners in wrought iron, which is more steel than the plate-style mounts at a similar rating, and the galvanized hardware in the box is a genuine bonus at this level.
Then the honest part. The 4.2 average is the lowest in this roundup, with the largest share of one-star feedback, and the complaints cluster around one thing: the black powder-coated painted steel wears. Buyers in coastal areas report finish breakdown faster than they would like, so if you live in salt air, a galvanized or stainless carrier is a better long-term bet.
Is the extra bulk a problem on a boat trailer?
At 13.58 inches deep, this is the bulkiest tongue mount in the group, and on a short tongue it can push the wheel close to the launch bower or the coupler. Check the clearance behind the coupler before committing, especially on a boat trailer with a tight transom area.
It is also larger than the elevated mounts, so verify the ground clearance you have on your access road before ordering.
When to pick it anyway
Choose it when bolt pattern coverage matters more than finish longevity, when you swap wheels between trailers regularly, or when you need 6-lug and 8-lug capability without a stake pocket. The single-wrench install and the included hardware keep it competitive on both effort and cost.
Pair it with a cable lock, since there is no locking feature, and recheck the mounting bolts after the first few hundred miles.
12. Seachoice Lockable U-Bolt Carrier – Best Marine Lockable U-Bolt for Boat Trailers
Seachoice Lockable Spare Tire Carrier for Boat Trailer
Lockable U-bolt design
Fits tongue or frame up to 3 inch wide
8 to 14 inch and most 15 inch wheels
Pros
- Lockable design deters tire theft without extra parts
- In continuous production since 2003
- so the design is proven
- Fits 8 to 14 inch and most 15 inch wheels on 4 or 5 hole rims
- Mounts to tongue or frame up to 3 inches wide
- Well-known marine hardware brand
Cons
- Padlock is not included
- you supply your own
- Tongue or frame width limited to 3 inches
- Does not cover 6 or 8 lug wheels
- Heavier U-bolt steel adds weight versus aluminum options
Boat trailers live a hard life, and this carrier has been in continuous production since 2003 with the same simple architecture: a U-bolt that clamps to the tongue or frame and can be locked closed. It is the oldest design in our roundup, and that longevity is itself a form of quality signal in a category where designs rarely change.
The lock point is the reason to choose it over the cheaper U-bolt option. Theft of spare tires from parked trailers is a recurring theme across owner forums, and a U-bolt that locks closed with a padlock you supply addresses it without any additional hardware.
Wheel coverage is 4 or 5 hole rims from 8 inch up to 14 inch, plus most 15 inch wheels, which covers the trailer spare range on the overwhelming majority of boat trailers. The tongue or frame it clamps to can be up to 3 inches wide.
Seachoice is a marine hardware brand, and that matters for a part that lives on a boat trailer in salt water, in a launch queue, and in a wet storage yard.
Is the padlock extra cost worth it?
Almost certainly, if your trailer spends time away from your house. The carrier does not include the lock, so budget for a small weather-resistant padlock, and keep the spare wheel and carrier keys together rather than clipping them to the trailer.
For a trailer stored in a locked garage, it is optional, and a plain U-bolt carrier will do the same job for less.
What are the limits?
The 3 inch tongue width is the hard stop, and it is narrower than several tongue-plate options in this roundup. If your frame rail is a 3.5 inch beam, this carrier will not close around it.
It also does not handle 6-lug or 8-lug wheels, and the heavier U-bolt steel it uses to resist corrosion adds weight next to an aluminum option like the Pit Posse bracket.
How to Measure Your Trailer Before You Order
Nearly every fitment complaint we read traces back to a measurement that was skipped. Before you buy any carrier in this list, take ten minutes and get four numbers.
Measure the tongue or frame member width and height. Measure across the flat where the carrier will clamp, and measure the height of the box section itself. Write both down. Most tongue plates in this roundup top out at 3 to 4 inches wide and 4 to 5 inches high.
Count the lugs and measure the bolt circle. Count the studs on your spare wheel, then measure the distance from the center of one stud to the center of the adjacent stud and multiply by two. That gives you the bolt circle diameter, which is the number that actually matters.
Check the wheel diameter and dish depth. A U-bolt carrier needs a shaft long enough to pass the tire, so note the outside diameter. A recessed-lug-hole alloy wheel rules out almost every plate-style mount in this list.
Look for a stake pocket before assuming a flat tongue. If your tongue has a square tube pocket welded into it, a stake pocket mount is dramatically more stable than any clamp-on option and is worth the extra hardware cost.
If you also plan to carry a spare inflator for roadside fixes, our [portable tire inflator roundup](https://irlentwincities.com/best-portable-tire-inflators/) covers the units that pair well with a tongue-mounted setup.
Buying Guide: Match the Carrier to Your Trailer
Where is the best place to put a spare tire on a trailer?
On the tongue or a side frame rail for open trailers, and on an interior wall for enclosed ones. The tongue is the default because it is the only structural point every trailer shares, and mounting there keeps weight forward and centered. A side or A-frame mount adds no length to the trailer. A wall mount inside an enclosed trailer keeps the spare from becoming a projectile and frees cargo floor. A receiver mount is best when you want ground-level access, but it competes with a bike rack for the same hitch.
What is the 50/50 rule for spare tires?
A spare tire should be the same size and type as the tires currently on the trailer, and no smaller. The reasoning is traction and wear. A smaller spare has less rubber on the road, so it wears faster and grips differently, and in an emergency you want the tire that will behave most like the tire you drove off on. The 50/50 reference is the historical bias in vehicle design, where roughly half the drive wheels contribute their share of traction, and a mismatched spare disrupts that. For a trailer, treat it as a rule: match the tire and the wheel.
Check the weight rating before anything else
Capacity figures in this category are not consistent between brands, which is a genuine problem when you are comparing. Published ratings in this roundup run from 120 lb on the forged iron tongue mounts to 165 lb on the CE Smith side mount. Weigh your actual spare, wheel and all, and buy a carrier rated comfortably above it.
Most trailer spares with 13 or 14 inch wheels land well under 100 lb, so a 120 lb rating is adequate for the majority of setups. Large truck spare wheels on a car-hauler are a different story, and there the 160 and 165 lb ratings earn their place.
Galvanized, powder coated, or aluminum
Galvanized steel is the best choice for salt water, boat ramps, and unheated storage. It is the most expensive per carrier here and the CE Smith mount uses 3/16 inch galvanized steel specifically for that reason. Powder coat is the common middle ground and resists corrosion well until the paint is scratched, which is why finish durability was the top complaint on the VEVOR model. Aluminum never rusts and will not mark a tire, but it is less stiff and needs a solid backing surface.
If you store outdoors near the coast, rule out painted steel you cannot inspect.
Locking is a real decision, not an extra
Owners across trailer forums report spare tires and carriers being taken from parking lots, and a carrier with a lock point costs little more than one without. The Attwood 11090-3 has threaded arms that accept a padlock, the Seachoice U-bolt locks closed with a padlock you supply, and the FIERYRED is available in a locking version. Everything else needs a separate cable lock or a wheel lock through the lug holes.
Do you need folding, swinging, or fixed
Folding and swing-away designs exist to give access to a cargo area behind the spare, not to make the tire itself easier to remove, and that is worth knowing before you buy one expecting easier wheel changes. Swing-down models also show visible play, which owners frequently mistake for a defect. Fixed mounts like the plate-style carriers in this roundup never move, which is why they are the quiet choice for most trailers.
Material weight and solo installation
Carriers range from 12.8 ounces for the aluminum Pit Posse bracket to 6.8 pounds for the CE Smith side mount. On a tongue-heavy trailer, holding a 6 pound plate overhead while threading bolts is a two-person job, so factor an extra set of hands into your plan if you are buying anything at the heavy end.
How Each Mounting Style Installs
Tongue mount plates
Position the plate on the tongue, align the wheel against it, and bolt through the lug holes into the plate with the supplied hardware. No drilling, no welding, and the fastest install in the category. The one thing to check is that the plate sits flat and the wheel does not contact the coupler or a jack tube behind it.
U-bolt side mounts
Thread the U-bolt from underneath the frame member, pass it through the wheel, and tighten the nuts or arms on the far side. The entire install is one hole pattern and two fasteners. Check the tire does not rub the frame while you tighten, and recheck the clamp after the first long trip.
Stake pocket mounts
Drop the carrier into the pocket, lock the carriage screw and bracket with the spring sheet, then mount the tire with cone nuts. Expect to shorten the carrier body with a hacksaw on some pocket depths so the bottom bolts up tight. This is the most involved install in the roundup and the most stable when done correctly.
Wall mount brackets
Mark the wall, drill for the supplied bolt, pass the bolt through the plate and the wall, and hang the wheel. The included bolt lengths cover most walls, and the wedge or nut design holds the tire flat against the wall. Install with the slot facing up rather than down so a loosening bolt cannot let the tire fall.
For tightening the lug nuts on any of these, use the two-wrench method: hold the stud with one wrench while tightening the nut with the other. This prevents the stud from rotating and stripping the threads in the wheel, which is the standard failure on an aluminum wheel.
Fixing Wobble, Rattle and Fitment Problems
Wobble is the most common complaint in this entire category, and in most cases it is either normal by design or has an identifiable cause. Forum threads on trailer and RV boards are overwhelmingly troubleshooting threads, and the same handful of fixes keep reappearing.
The spare moves at the edge but the mount is tight
If the carrier itself does not move but the wheel rocks side to side, the usual culprit is ovalized bolt holes in the mount, particularly on a bumper-mounted bracket that has been in service. The accepted fix is to shim the bolt with a flat washer or a thin plate to take up the slack, and several owners report that alone removes an inch of movement. Swapping a clevis pin for a bolt with a lock nut tightens the remaining play.
The whole carrier swings and there is noise over bumps
That is the swing-down design working as intended, not a fault. Swing-down sections exist to give access to a storage compartment behind the spare, and a small amount of play at the pivot is normal. If it bothers you, owners have welded the swing section in place to convert it to a fixed mount, which is permanent but stable.
The tire rubs the frame or the tongue jack
Check whether the tire touches on the tongue jack before blaming the carrier, because jack position is often the problem. Relocating a stabilizer jack is described on owner forums as the single hardest step in an undermount or side-mount installation, and it is very manageable with a length of channel and a welder. Check tongue jack clearance before ordering a carrier with a deep offset, and check it with the trailer fully coupled and the jack fully extended.
Wrong bolts, loose fasteners, and rattling nuts
A carrier mounted with screws too short for the frame thickness will rattle and may work loose. If the included hardware does not bite, use longer carriage bolts or add washers, and recheck everything after the first 100 miles. For lug nuts, star pattern tightening in a crisscross sequence is the standard habit and it matters more on a carrier than on a car because the wheel is cantilevered off the mount.
Check for a rubbing point before you blame the tire
A rubbing mark on the tire sidewall almost always traces to the carrier bracket touching, not to a bent wheel. Mark the contact point with a piece of chalk, move the tire, and check again. If the bracket is the culprit and it is a plate mount, shimming the wheel back with washers on the studs usually solves it permanently.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best spare tire holder for a utility trailer?
For most utility and boat trailers, a tongue mount plate carrier that holds 4-lug and 5-lug wheels is the best balance of stability, install speed, and cost. Measure your tongue width and height first, since most fitments fail on an oversized tongue rather than on the wheel pattern.
Where is the best place to put a spare tire on a trailer?
The tongue is the default answer because it is the only structural point every trailer shares, and it keeps weight centered. A side or A-frame mount adds no trailer length, a wall mount inside an enclosed trailer frees cargo floor, and a receiver mount gives ground-level access but competes with a bike rack for the hitch.
What is the 50/50 rule for spare tires?
A spare should be the same size and type as the tires currently on the trailer, and no smaller. A smaller spare puts less rubber on the road, wears faster, and grips differently in exactly the moment you need it most. Match the tire and match the wheel.
How do I measure my trailer for a spare tire carrier?
Get four numbers: the width and height of your tongue or frame member, the lug count and bolt circle of your spare wheel, the wheel diameter, and whether your tongue has a welded stake pocket. Bolt circle diameter is measured center of one stud to center of the adjacent stud, then doubled.
What are the different types of trailer spare tire mounts?
Five main types: tongue mount plates, U-bolt side mounts, stake pocket mounts, interior wall mount brackets, and receiver or swing-away mounts. Plate and stake pocket mounts are the most stable, U-bolts are the cheapest and most portable, wall mounts save enclosed trailer cargo space, and receiver mounts trade hitch access for ground-level tire access.
Why does my trailer spare tire wobble on the mount?
If the carrier is tight and only the wheel moves, the bolt holes are likely ovalized, and a washer or thin shim takes up the slack. If the whole carrier swings, that is usually a swing-down pivot behaving as designed. A carrier bolted with screws too short for the frame thickness will also rattle and can work loose.
The Verdict: Which Spare Tire Carrier to Buy
After comparing all twelve, the best spare tire carrier for a trailer is the MaxxHaul 50214 for anyone with a standard tongue and a 4-lug or 5-lug spare. It has the deepest review history in the category, a raised profile that helps on boat ramps, and hardware that actually fits the job.
Go with the Attwood 11090-3 if theft is a concern, since its threaded arms accept a padlock and the 8.5 inch shaft covers a wide range of tire sizes. Pick the Qualward bracket when your spare is 6-lug or your tongue is beefier than 3 inches. For an enclosed trailer, the Adamoss wall mount keeps the wheel flat and off the floor, and the Pit Posse 802 does the same job in 12.8 ounces. If your tongue has a stake pocket, the MY RUSTIC mount is the most stable carrier we tested and covers everything from 4-lug to 8-lug.
Whatever you pick in 2026, measure the tongue and the bolt circle before you order. That ten minutes of measuring is the difference between a carrier that fits perfectly and one that comes back in a box.